I used the Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra and iPhone 17 Pro Max, and I'm done pretending one is clearly better
Comparing the Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra with the iPhone 17 Pro Max remains tricky because they target different audiences. It’s not a straightforward competition, as each phone delivers a distinct experience shaped by its ecosystem and design philosophy.
Apple changed the outside but forgot the inside
The iPhone 17 Pro Max looks refreshed externally, but the internal experience feels familiar. Apple’s focus on design doesn’t necessarily translate into the same leap forward in performance or innovation many expected this year.
Differences and similarities
Unlike comparing Apple’s flagship with Google’s Pixel 10 Pro XL—where the competition is closer—the S25 Ultra and iPhone 17 Pro Max bring their own strengths. Both are excellent in their own right, appealing to users prioritizing different values: Apple for ecosystem stability, Samsung for hardware versatility.
Reasons to choose one over the other
- If you’re tired of Apple’s walled garden, the Galaxy S25 Ultra offers a refreshing Android experience with more freedom and customization.
- If you trust Apple’s reliability and value its seamless ecosystem, the iPhone 17 Pro Max remains a strong choice despite limited changes inside.
Galaxy S25 Ultra impressions
“Whenever I use the Galaxy S25 Ultra, a few things jump out at me.”
Samsung has made notable improvements this year. The 6.9‑inch Dynamic AMOLED screen is stunning and outshines the iPhone 17 Pro Max display. The enhanced anti-reflective coating significantly reduces glare, making outdoor visibility better than on Apple’s model.
“I love using phones where the screen feels like I’m touching what’s on the display, and the Galaxy S25 Ultra gives me that experience.”
This tactile precision creates a sense of immersion that the iPhone struggles to match. It’s a reminder that hardware refinement can change how we physically interact with technology.
Author’s Summary
The Galaxy S25 Ultra impresses with its screen and usability, while the iPhone 17 Pro Max feels polished but familiar—each excels for different types of users.