Donald Clarke: Jimmy Kimmel was very polite about his recent Irish trip. But he is mistaken

Donald Clarke on Jimmy Kimmel’s Irish Trip

Jimmy Kimmel recently praised Ireland's decency, friendliness, and political maturity during his visit. While the TV host was very polite about his trip, Donald Clarke argues that Irish people are no more polite or generous than Americans.

A Personal Anecdote about New Yorkers

About four thousand years ago, Clarke visited New York City on a J1 visa. He tried to find work in a familiar field but had to first speak with the union representing that workforce. The woman he met was incredibly helpful, offering advice, alternative job options, and many useful contacts. After 30 minutes, she warmly said:

“Now, don’t let anyone tell you New Yorkers are rude.”

Clarke had only found New Yorkers occasionally brusque but no less polite than other big city residents.

Reflection on Kimmel’s Comments

Watching Kimmel's discussion of Ireland reminded Clarke of that New York experience. Kimmel mentioned leprechauns early on, but mainly focused on complimenting Irish behavior and politics.

Summary

Clarke suggests that Irish politeness is comparable to that of New Yorkers and challenges the idea that Ireland’s hospitality is uniquely exceptional.

Author’s summary: Donald Clarke highlights that Irish politeness matches that of Americans, offering a balanced perspective against overly flattering portrayals.

more

The Irish Times The Irish Times — 2025-11-02

More News