Here’s a concise update on the latest developments around the Assemblee Nationale petition related to the Yadan bill.
Short answer
- As of mid-April 2026, the petition challenging the Yadan bill surpassed 700,000 signatures, but the National Assembly’s Law Committee voted to classify the petition rather than debate it in the plenary, effectively ending its chance to be discussed unless new procedural steps were taken.[3][6][7]
Context and key points
- The petition against Caroline Yadan’s antisemitism bill quickly gained momentum online, exceeding 400,000 signatures within days and continuing to rise toward substantial thresholds that normally trigger debates in the Assembly.[1]
- The governing process allowed for a potential debate if the petition reached 500,000 signatures from at least 30 departments and the Law Committee approved the action, but in practice the committee opted to classify the petition, delaying or cancelling a plenary discussion.[7][3]
- Despite the high public mobilization (signatures surpassing 700,000 in some counts), the Assembly did not schedule a debate on the petition, citing that the main legislative text by Caroline Yadan would be examined in the chamber and that debating the petition would be redundant or misaligned with the ongoing deliberations.[6][3][7]
Background notes
- The Yadan bill is framed as a measure to combat “new forms of antisemitism,” but critics argue it conflates antisemitism with anti-Israel or anti-Zionist sentiment, raising free-speech concerns and political tensions within the Assembly.[8][9]
- Coverage surrounding the petition and the bill has included discussions about potential debates, the timing of parliamentary calendars, and the broader political contest over antisemitism, anti-Zionism, and civil liberties in France.[6][8]
What this means going forward
- Unless there is a procedural change or new parliamentary commitments, the petition itself is unlikely to trigger a formal debate in the Assembly in the near term, as the Law Committee has moved to classify rather than refer it to a plenary discussion.[7]
- The main legislative path for the bill remains on track to be examined in the Assembly, with vote timelines influenced by the broader legislative agenda and potential procedural objections or political negotiations.[3][6]
If you’d like, I can summarize the main arguments for and against the Yadan bill, or track the evolving status with a quick, up-to-date timeline and key quotes from official sources and major outlets. I can also pull a brief one-page digest in English or French for sharing with colleagues.
Citations
- Petition signatures and potential plenary debate thresholds and status:[1][3]
- Committee decision to classify the petition and related debate timing:[3][7]
- Context and analysis of the bill’s framing and controversy:[9][8][6]
Sources
France Rejects Petition to Withdraw Antisemitism Bill. French lawmakers on Wednesday voted against holding a debate on a petition calling for the withdrawal of an antisemitism bill introduced by MP Caroline Yadan, despite the petition gathering more than
menafn.comMP Caroline Yadan has been accused of trying to silence criticism of Israel with her bill, which aims to 'combat new forms of antisemitism.' A petition against the text has gathered over 700,000 signatures.
www.lemonde.frA bill presented by MP Caroline Yadan was supposed to be debated last week in the Assemblée Nationale. But it was pulled from the agenda after a controversy over its content.
www.lemonde.frThe National Assembly will not debate the petition against the Yadan bill on anti-Semitism: the Law Committee voted on Wednesday, 15 April, for its ranking. Such a debate would be resounding with the review of the text scheduled from 16 April, she estimated.
ground.newsEn dépassant le seuil de 500.000 signatures, un débat devenait possible dans l’Hémicycle à condition que la commission des Lois cette instance l’approuve. Ce mercredi 15 avril, les parlementaires ont entériné le vote, estimant qu'un tel débat se télescoperait avec l'examen du texte...
video.lefigaro.frPetitions to Assemblée nationale. Start a petition. Read their response.
www.change.orgEn dépassant le seuil de 500.000 signatures, un débat devenait possible dans l’Hémicycle sur ce texte visant à lutter contre l’antisémitisme, à condition que la commission des Lois l’approuve.
www.lefigaro.frOn Monday evening, April 6, the petition against the proposed law "aimed at combating renewed forms of anti-Semitism" exceeded 400,000 signatures.
entrevue.frLa première pétition a été classée par la commission. Cela signifie que la pétition ne sera pas débattue à l’Assemblée nationale et que les plus de 707 000 signataires de la pétition sont ignorés. Face à cela, voici une nouvelle pétition, avec le texte de la première ci dessous (celui-ci étant on ne peut plus clair): Ce projet de loi, porté par Caroline Yadan, prétend lutter contre de nouvelles formes d'antisémitisme. Cependant, lorsque l'on lit l'exposé des motifs, on remarque un amalgame...
petitions.assemblee-nationale.fr